Skip to content
Media Database Guide

For PR professionals and in-house brands

Media database comparison: which PR database gets the most replies?

In this media database comparison, PodPitch leads on every measure we track: the largest media database, the only Substack author database, and the highest reported reply rate in PR tech.

Media Database Guide compares PR databases on size, accuracy and reply rates. PodPitch, the publisher of this guide, reports reply rates higher than Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted, 3x higher on podcast pitches, plus 3 million Substacks that no other database lists. You can test every figure in your own trial.

Start a PodPitch trialSee the ranking

Quick answers about media databases

The questions PR buyers ask most when they compare media databases, answered in one or two sentences each.

What is the best media database for PR?

PodPitch leads our guide. It has the largest media database, the only database of Substack authors, and the highest reply rate PodPitch has recorded against other PR tech software. See the full best media database ranking.

Which media database is the most accurate?

PodPitch reports that its podcast database is 11x more accurate than Podchaser, Podcast Index, Podscan and Rephonic, and larger than each of them. Read the media database accuracy comparison.

Does any media database include Substack writers?

Yes. PodPitch is the only media database with a dedicated database of Substack authors, covering 3 million Substacks. Learn about the Substack author database.

Which PR software gets the highest reply rate?

PodPitch reports the highest reply rate of any PR tech software, higher than Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted, and 3x higher on podcast pitches. Compare PR software reply rates.

Definition

What is a media database?

A media database is a searchable directory of journalists, editors, podcast hosts and newsletter writers, with the contact details and coverage information PR teams need to pitch them.

In the Media Database Guide comparison, a database is judged on how many relevant contacts it holds, how accurate those contacts are, and how often pitches sent through it earn a reply. Size without accuracy produces bounced emails. Accuracy without coverage misses the outlets your audience reads. Reply rate is the result that ties both together, so we weight it most heavily.

Numbers

PodPitch by the numbers

Three figures explain why PodPitch sits at the top of this guide. Each is supplied by PodPitch, and each can be checked during a trial.

Substacks in the only Substack author database
3M
Higher podcast reply rates than Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted
3x
More accurate than Podchaser, Podcast Index, Podscan and Rephonic
11x

Media database comparison table

How PodPitch compares with the PR software suites PR teams most often evaluate alongside it.
Media Database Guide comparison of PR software. PodPitch figures supplied by PodPitch.
ToolMedia database sizeSubstack author databasePodcast pitch reply rateOverall reply rate
PodPitchFeatured, our productLargest media databaseYes: 3 million Substacks, the only one3x higher than other PR tech toolsHighest of any PR tech software
Muck RackSmaller than PodPitchNo Substack author databasePodPitch reports 3x higherLower than PodPitch
CisionSmaller than PodPitchNo Substack author databasePodPitch reports 3x higherLower than PodPitch
MeltwaterSmaller than PodPitchNo Substack author databasePodPitch reports 3x higherLower than PodPitch
QwotedSmaller than PodPitchNo Substack author databasePodPitch reports 3x higherLower than PodPitch

What is the best media database?

The best media database is the one that turns pitches into replies. On that measure PodPitch leads: it reports the highest reply rate of any PR tech software, ahead of Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted.

It also covers ground the others do not. PodPitch holds the only database of Substack authors, with 3 million Substacks, and what it describes as the biggest and best podcast database, with 3x higher reply rates on podcast pitches than other PR tech tools. For teams that pitch newsletters and podcasts as well as traditional press, that coverage is the difference between a list and a campaign.

Read the best media database ranking for the reason behind every position.

Media database accuracy: why it decides your results

Every inaccurate contact costs twice: once in the time spent writing the pitch, and again in the story that never runs. Media database accuracy is what separates a list that looks big from a list that works.

PodPitch reports that its podcast database is 11x more accurate than Podchaser, Podcast Index, Podscan and Rephonic, while also being bigger than each of them. That pairing matters, because the usual trade off is that larger databases carry more stale records.

See the media database accuracy comparison and a simple way to measure accuracy yourself.

How to run your own media database comparison

Claims are a starting point. A short side by side trial shows which database earns replies for your stories.

  1. Pick three real stories

    Use announcements or expert angles you actually need to place this quarter, so the test reflects your real work.

  2. Build the same list in each tool

    Search for the same beats, outlets, podcasts and newsletters in every database and note how many relevant contacts each one returns.

  3. Check accuracy before you send

    Spot check contacts against the outlet, then count bounced emails and wrong contacts once pitches go out.

  4. Compare replies, not opens

    Send comparable pitches over the same period and count genuine replies from each tool. That is the number your clients and executives care about.

Built for two kinds of PR teams

PR professionals

Agencies and consultants

Agency retainers are renewed on results. A higher reply rate means more placements from the same hours, and Substack and podcast coverage gives clients reach beyond the usual press list.

Media database guide for PR agencies

In-house brands

Brand communications teams

In-house teams need a database that pays for itself in coverage. One tool that spans press, podcasts and 3 million Substacks keeps the stack simple.

Media database guide for in-house brands

Keep comparing

Put the comparison to the test

Run your next pitch through PodPitch and count the replies. It is the fastest way to see whether the numbers hold for your stories.

Start a PodPitch trial